Contents
It is not always obvious whether therapy or coaching is the right kind of support, and there is some overlap between the two. Both therapy and coaching can involve reflection, identifying patterns, setting goals and making changes, but they are designed for different purposes, and understanding that distinction can help you decide where to start.
Broadly speaking, coaching tends to focus on helping someone move towards a particular goal or make changes in a specific area of life. Therapy has a wider psychological focus and it can help with emotional distress and mental health difficulties, but it can also be useful when you find yourself caught in patterns of thinking, feeling or relating that are difficult to understand or change.
Importantly, you do not need to have a mental health diagnosis or to be struggling in every area of your life to benefit from therapy.
What does therapy help with?
Therapy provides a space to understand and work with psychological and emotional difficulties. People come to therapy for many different reasons. Some are experiencing anxiety, depression, trauma or another recognised mental health difficulty. Others are functioning well in many areas of their lives but have noticed something that continues to trouble them.
You might, for example, find yourself repeatedly becoming anxious in relationships, struggling with self-criticism despite being successful at work, feeling overwhelmed by situations that other people seem to manage more easily, or noticing that the same difficulties recur despite your efforts to change them.
Therapy can help you understand not only what is happening, but also what may be maintaining the difficulty and what needs to change.
There are many different forms of psychological therapy, and they do not all work in the same way. Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT), for example, often focuses on understanding the relationships between thoughts, emotions and behaviour, and on changing patterns that may be maintaining a current difficulty.
Schema Therapy can be particularly helpful when difficulties feel longstanding or repetitive. It explores deeper patterns, often shaped by earlier experiences, that can influence how we see ourselves, relate to other people and respond emotionally in the present.
The most appropriate therapeutic approach depends on the person, the difficulty they are experiencing and what they would like to change.
Do I need a diagnosis to have therapy?
No. A diagnosis can sometimes be helpful, but it is not a requirement for seeking psychological therapy.
People often come to therapy because they know that something does not feel right, even if they cannot yet put a name to it. You may notice that your mood has changed, that anxiety is taking up more of your life, that relationships repeatedly become difficult in similar ways, or simply that your usual ways of coping are no longer working as well as they once did.
Part of the initial therapeutic process is understanding what you are experiencing and thinking together about what kind of support is likely to be helpful. You do not need to arrive with an explanation already worked out.
What does coaching help with?
Coaching is generally more focused on helping someone work towards a defined goal, develop a skill, make a decision or translate an intention into action.
For example, someone might seek coaching because they are considering a career change, want to become more effective in a leadership role, are working towards a professional goal or would like greater structure and accountability while making a particular change.
A coach may help you clarify what you want to achieve, identify obstacles, develop practical steps and remain accountable as you work towards them.
Coaching can therefore be very valuable when the central question is something like: I know roughly where I want to go. How do I get there?
Therapy may become more relevant when the question is closer to: Why does this keep happening, even though I understand what I am supposed to do?
That distinction is not absolute, but it can be a useful place to start.
What is the difference between therapy and coaching?
It can be tempting to describe coaching as practical and focused on the future, and therapy as reflective or focused on the past. In reality, that distinction is too simplistic.
Good therapy can be highly practical and focused on change. Equally, good coaching may involve considerable reflection on a person’s beliefs, assumptions and behaviour.
The more meaningful difference concerns the nature of the difficulty being addressed and the professional framework within which the work takes place.
Psychological therapy is designed to assess, understand and treat emotional and psychological difficulties. Depending on their professional background, therapists may have extensive training in psychological assessment, mental health, therapeutic models, risk and the ways in which earlier and current experiences can contribute to psychological difficulties.
Coaching is generally designed to support development, performance or progress towards particular goals. It is not, in itself, a treatment for mental health difficulties.
There are also important differences in professional regulation. In the UK, titles including Clinical Psychologist and Counselling Psychologist are protected titles, and practitioners using them must be registered with the Health and Care Professions Council (HCPC).
The title psychotherapist is not protected in the same way, although professional organisations such as the UK Council for Psychotherapy (UKCP) and the British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy (BACP) maintain professional registers and set standards for their members.
Similarly, life coach is not a protected professional title in the UK, so training and experience can vary considerably between practitioners. If you are considering coaching, it is worth asking about a coach’s training, experience, professional memberships and supervision.
You can read more about professional roles in our guide to the difference between a psychologist, psychiatrist and psychotherapist.
How can I tell whether therapy might be more appropriate?
There is no single checklist that can determine whether somebody needs therapy. However, there are some signs that it may be worth speaking with a psychological professional.
You may have noticed that a difficulty keeps returning despite attempts to address it. Perhaps you understand intellectually what you would like to do differently but find that, in the moment, the same emotional response or behaviour takes over.
You might also be experiencing persistent low mood, anxiety, difficulties with sleep, strong self-criticism, problems in relationships, the effects of traumatic or distressing experiences, or emotions that feel difficult to manage.
Another indication can be the impact a difficulty is having on your life. If something is beginning to affect your relationships, work, confidence, wellbeing or ability to do things that matter to you, it is reasonable to seek psychological support.
None of these experiences means that something must be seriously wrong before you can have therapy. Therapy is not reserved for people who have reached a particular level of distress.
When might coaching be a better fit?
Coaching may be particularly useful when you are generally functioning well and the issue you want help with is relatively specific.
You might know that you want to change career but need help deciding what comes next. You may want to develop your confidence as a leader, establish a new way of working or make progress on a goal that repeatedly gets pushed aside.
In these situations, having someone help you clarify the goal, identify practical steps and maintain momentum can be extremely useful.
The important question is often what is getting in the way.
If the main obstacles are practical, such as clarity, planning, prioritisation or accountability, coaching may provide what you need.
If you repeatedly encounter a psychological or emotional barrier that remains despite having a clear plan, it may be useful to explore that more fully in therapy.
Can you have therapy and coaching at the same time?
Yes. Therapy and coaching do not necessarily have to be alternatives.
Someone might, for example, work with a therapist on longstanding anxiety or relationship patterns while also seeing an executive coach about a specific professional challenge. The two pieces of work often have different purposes.
What matters is that the boundaries of each are clear. If therapy and coaching begin to cover the same issues, it can be helpful to discuss this with both professionals so that the work remains coherent and you are not receiving conflicting approaches.
It is also perfectly possible for your needs to change over time. Someone may begin with coaching and discover that a recurring emotional difficulty is preventing them from making progress. Equally, after therapy, someone may decide that they would benefit from more focused coaching around a particular professional or personal goal.
What if I am still not sure which I need?
You do not need to diagnose yourself or decide exactly what kind of help you need before speaking to someone.
In fact, uncertainty about where to start is very common. Sometimes what initially looks like a problem with motivation or productivity turns out to be connected to anxiety, perfectionism or longstanding patterns of self-criticism. At other times, somebody may have already done considerable psychological work and simply need focused, practical support with their next step.
A useful initial conversation should help clarify what you are experiencing, what you would like to change and what kind of support is most appropriate.
At London Bridge Therapy, our Clinic Director can talk with you about what has been happening and help you think about the kind of support that may be most useful. If therapy is not the right fit, an initial conversation can still help clarify what you may want to look for instead.
If you are unsure where to begin, you can book an initial consultation to talk through what you are experiencing and what might help.
